Advertisement

Arch Manning impresses in Lone Star Showdown: Report card from Texas A&M upset

Arch Manning showed real growth against Texas A&M, using his legs, protecting the ball, and leading Texas in a high-stakes rivalry. Full report card and analysis.
Dorrington Myers
Dorrington Myers

Hook'em Headlines

Nov 28, 2025; Austin, Texas, USA; Texas Longhorns quarterback Arch Manning keeps the ball and runs for a touchdown during the second half against the Texas A&M Aggies at Darrell K Royal-Texas Memorial Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Scott Wachter-Imagn Images / Scott Wachter-Imagn Images

Texas (9–3, 6–2 SEC) and Texas A&M (11–1, 7–1 SEC) renewed a rivalry that never disappoints, and this edition delivered everything fans expected—fireworks, momentum swings, and a major development leap from one quarterback. Manning vs. Reed. Longhorns vs. Aggies. Classic.

What was on the line?

Texas A&M: A trip to the SEC Championship Game.

Texas: Survival in the College Football Playoff hunt.

Here’s Arch Manning’s full game report card:

Stat line

14/29 passing, 179 yards, 1 TD

7 carries, 53 rushing yards (7.3 YPC), 1 rushing TD

The first half was uneven as Texas searched for rhythm, but once Manning settled in, everything shifted.

What I liked

Used his legs

This is Manning’s superpower. Against one of the SEC’s best defenses, he averaged 7.3 yards per carry—a mark many running backs haven’t reached this season. His mobility kept drives alive, extended plays, and became the difference between winning and losing.

Progressions

Manning took a noticeable step forward. He worked through reads, stayed controlled in the pocket, and delivered the football with conviction. It wasn’t flashy—it was steady, disciplined quarterbacking, and it mattered.

A completely clean sheet. No interceptions. No offensive turnovers. You win rivalry games by valuing possessions, and Manning did that at a high level.

Game Grade: B

Final thoughts

Will this game push Manning into any major award conversations? No. But it does reinforce something more important: he’s fully capable of running this offense—and has been for a while. Quarterback development is rarely linear, and this was another meaningful step in his evolution.

What impressed most was his poise. When the start was rough, he didn’t spiral. He didn’t press. He played within the structure, trusted his reads, and executed winning football—something young quarterbacks often struggle with in high-stakes environments.

Now, Texas waits.
Best-case: a backdoor CFP berth.
Worst-case: a high-profile bowl matchup.

Either way, 2026 sets the stage for Manning to make a legitimate run at the Heisman conversation. After a performance like this, there’s no doubt he’s trending in the right direction.

Dorrington Myers

Dorrington Myers

Dorrington Myers is an Army veteran, quarterback specialist, and member of the Pro Style Football Association who brings a wealth of expertise to his role as a contributor for Hook’Em Headlines on FanSided. He also works with DraftHBCU and Mike Farrell Sports as a quarterback specialist and analyst, providing detailed insights into player development, offensive strategy, and scouting. A graduate of VCU with a Bachelor of Science in Sociology, Myers has built his reputation as both a coach and writer by blending on-field training experience with sharp football analysis. He has been recognized for his work across multiple football platforms and continues to study the evolving quarterback position in depth. Beyond football, he enjoys mentoring young athletes, creating developmental resources for quarterbacks, and spending time with his family.