Skip to main content

Cam Coleman's hefty price tag has only rubbed salt in the wound of his underperformance

The Texas Longhorns paid a lot of money to bring Cam Coleman to the 40 Acres, and he simply hasn't met expectations.
BySam Fariss
Cam Coleman, Oct. 17, Florida at Texas
Cam Coleman, Oct. 17, Florida at Texas | Icon Sportswire/GettyImages

Maybe it's just me (I'm fairly confident it isn't), but when the Texas Longhorns shelled out $3 million (yes, $3,000,000) to bring Cam Coleman to the 40 Acres out of the transfer portal, I expected him to put up just about a billion receiving yards for just about a million touchdowns (give or take a few).

And, to put it mildly, Coleman has fallen well short of those expectations.

So far this season, Coleman is the Horns' WR3, with just 23 receptions for 409 yards. Yes, he has the most receiving touchdowns (7) on the team, but he simply hasn't been that extra "oomph" factor that I thought he would be.

In fact, just a few days ago, when Texas was mounting its fourth-quarter comeback to defeat the LSU Tigers, Coleman went the entire game without a single catch. That's right: zero (0) catches for zero (0) yards.

Instead, head coach Steve Sarkisian and quarterback Arch Manning utilized Ryan Wingo and true freshman Jermaine Bishop Jr. during their march down the field on the game-winning drive.

Clearly, Coleman's underperformance (I haven't even gotten into his dropped passes on virtually locked-in touchdowns) has created an aura of distrust from his head coach and quarterback. And he has been paid $3 million while doing so.

4 stats that prove Cam Coleman wasn't worth his $3 million price tag

Beyond the zero-yard performance against LSU, Coleman simply hasn't been the wideout that virtually everyone thought he would be at Texas, especially as one of the highest-paid receivers in the entire country.

  • Coleman's 61.1% catch rate ranks 344th among 534 qualifying FBS receivers and tight ends
  • Coleman's 32 targets rank lower than the number of receptions for 200 qualifying FBS receivers and tight ends
  • Coleman's $3 million NIL deal and 23 receptions equate to $130,434.78 per catch
  • Coleman's seven receiving touchdowns only rank 28th among qualifying FBS receivers and tight ends (tied with 13 other WRs and TEs)

Not only are his on-field stats disappointing, at best, but the amount of money that Texas is shelling out for the numbers he is producing is astronomical. Making over $130K per catch is absurd and something that most pros don't even see.

College Football Bracket Challenge

GET READY TO COMPETE

Pick your champion (you can change it later). We’ll email you when brackets open.

No purchase necessary. 50 U.S./D.C. 18+. Entry opens 3PM ET Dec 6, 2026 and closes 8PM ET Dec 18, 2026. Void where prohibited.See for complete details. The College Football Playoff (CFP) is not a sponsor or administrator of this contest.

For reference, former Longhorn wideout Xavier Worthy is making roughly $3.45 million this year for the Kansas City Chiefs. His 33 receptions equate to about $104,545 per catch, way less than Coleman's dollar-to-catch ratio (and the Chiefs have played one fewer game than the Horns have so far this year).

Furthermore, "fellow star" collegiate wide receivers like Miami's Malachi Toney and Ohio State's Jeremiah Smith are outperforming Coleman by a colossal measure.

Toney is making just $2 million to play for the Miami Hurricanes this year, and unfortunately went down with an injury ahead of the Canes' Week 10 game. However, he had already amassed 73 receptions for 1,027 yards and 13 touchdowns (that's $27,397 per catch).

Meanwhile, Smith is making $5 million as the wideout who entered the season as one of the best college football players in the entire nation. Even with the massive price tag he carries, his 80 receptions for 1,317 yards and 13 touchdowns equate to just $62,500 per catch.

In other words, Sarkisian and the Longhorns way overpaid for Coleman, and so far, he has continuously fallen short of that $3-million mark.

Luckily, Coleman isn't the only wideout on the roster, and a lot of his fellow receivers have been surpassing the expectations that were set for them before the season kicked off.

Steve Sarkisian's recruiting prowess highlighted by Texas's receiver corps

Beyond Wingo and Bishop, the Horns have been able to rely on a plethora of other wideouts and tight ends, including veteran wide receiver Emmett Mosley V and even running backs like Raleek Brown and redshirt freshman Michael Terry III.

As Wingo has cemented himself as Manning's go-to guy downfield, with 591 yards on 48 receptions, Mosley has emerged as Texas's WR2, with 541 yards on 34 catches.

Yardage-wise, Coleman is Texas's WR3, but he has the same number of receptions as Bishop, who has earned 11.0 yards per catch and four total receiving TDs as a true freshman (not a $3-million player).

Coleman isn't a bad player. In fact, he'll still probably be one of the top wide receivers selected in the 2027 NFL Draft. However, he has undeniably fallen short of the expectations that everyone, myself included, had for him this season, and it's past time for everyone to admit that fact.

Add us as a preferred source on Google